Facebook Comments: Good or Bad for Your Business?

Facebook is in the news yet again. The world’s leading social network last week updated its comment widget to allow personalized chats on third-party websites. Facebook says the free plugin will make life easy for publishers to add Facebook-themed commenting functionality to their websites.

As with any Facebook feature, there are mixed reactions on whether the new comment widget is – good, bad or neutral, especially for business users. Here’s my take on it.

How does Facebook Comment Plugin work?

Anonymous comments can often be rude, abusive and unpleasant. Facebook says it updated the Comments Box Plug-in, which links comments made on third party websites to a member’s Facebook account, to encourage personal and relevant conversations. The move is expected to minimize spam comments as it signals the end of anonymity.


Anonymity isn’t bad, but it’s heavily overused and abused in the social media world. Of course, the most obvious implication of this change is that users will be forced to think twice before they comment on any site. Therefore, a huge drop in number of comments can’t be ruled out.

TechCrunch adopted the Facebook comment plugin and observed the overall number of comments have fallen dramatically. While TechCrunch says it’s expected and “not a bad thing”, it may have serious implications for a business which thrives on traffic redirection and comments with inbound links.

The obvious benefit is that you get quality comments. There would be a decline in the number of useless comments.

Pros & Cons

TechCrunch team has done a wonderful job of highlighting the pros and cons of the new Facebook comments plugin. As expected, the benefits include a reduction in number of trolls, tighter integration with Facebook and the ability to socialize comments through Facebook “likes” feature.

The biggest disadvantage being the comments plugin does not work with Google and Twitter credentials. There are other issues as well – it compromises privacy as people may find their replies in your Facebook News stream reproduced on another site’s comments – not exactly a pleasant surprise. Further, if Facebook is blocked due to access restrictions, your site’s comments system falls flat.

It’s understandable that Facebook left out Twitter and Google on purpose. While the former is its closest competitor in social media, the latter is not in friends list. However, that accounts for a massive proportion of the daily web traffic and there’s no doubt that it will hurt the wide scale adoption of this plugin.

Good, bad or neutral?

Coming back to the original question – is the new Facebook comment plugin good, bad or neutral for your business? Do the pros outweigh the cons or vice-versa? IMO, there’s no one size fits all solution here. If your website gets quality anonymous comments, I see no reason to block them with this plugin. On the other hand, if your site is plagued with spam due to anonymous comments, the Facebook comments plugin is a blessing in disguise for your business.

Do you plan to use the Facebook comments plugin for moderating your website users? Please share your opinion by leaving a comment below this post.

Join the Conversation


  1. Gabriele Maidecchi       Reply

    I couldn’t be more against Facebook comments than I already am, honestly.
    It’s not about anonimity, I always comment with my real name and last name as you know, but, I simply don’t have a Facebook account. And I don’t intend to make one. The only account I have is a service account, with a fake name (it’s against the policy I know, but I don’t really care) that I use to admin some pages, and that’s about it.
    I frankly never had a use for Facebook and for sure commenting won’t be one that will move me to use it, so I don’t really understand why any blog would want to implement just that way of accepting user’s feedback. Adding the chance for FB people to comment, fine, having it as the ONLY method, not so.

    1. Douglas Idugboe       Reply

      That’s one of the biggest con to the system for me. There’s limitation to who can leave comments and for the fact that Facebook is the #1 blocked sites in most work places, would limit a site’s commenting reach.

      Thanks for another awesome take on this post Gabriele.

      1. Gabriele Maidecchi       Reply

        Woah yeah, I didn’t really think about Facebook being blocked. Bad issue indeed.

  2. Quay Morris       Reply

    I think there are a few factors that make Facebook comments a bad move for most people: quite a few businesses do block Facebook; as Gabriele mentioned, not everyone has a Facebook account; for some people, there is that privacy issue (I want my opinion to be heard, but I don’t want to be harassed).

    For me: I have a Facebook account, but I do NOT use my personal profile for any sort of business. I already have business contacts who want to friend me on Facebook and it’s just not happening, sorry. I keep business completely out of my personal profile, and I’d like to keep it that way. Commenting on a blog site from that profile could open me up to friend requests that, quite frankly, I don’t want.

    1. Douglas Idugboe       Reply

      Very valid points Quay. Welcome to the Smedio community!

  3. NGA       Reply


  4. Anonymous       Reply

    Here is how I look at it:

    Facebook is convenient. MOST people won’t bother to fill out a little form (even if it is just a name and email).

    With facebook comments, you can easily capture the comments of who would be too lazy in the first place.

    But there is a downside, too. Facebook comments don’t get indexed! I think the same goes for the Disqus comment system which you are using at the moment. I had it before but decided against it for the very reason.


    You can have both like on my blog at:


    Ryan Deiss also has the same thing. I am trying to figure out how to get them “tabbed” so it doesn’t take up so much vertical space though 😉

    – Dean

  5. Elizabeth Bennett       Reply

    Although I have a Facebook page, I prefer LinkedIn for professional networking which sets a boundary between professional colleagues and my pals and relatives. Blogging is set up differently and is not done randomly and anonymously.

    If you are wondering if Facebook is the right place to market your businesses, I’d like to share my thoughts with you on this topic.

    After doing research on marketing on “social networking sites” I am now differentiating between “LinkedIn” which include professional contacts and “Facebook” which include my relatives and pals.

    I have not let clients or employees as sub-contractors or vendors “friend me” on my personal Facebook page and I never will.

    As an alternative to my personal Facebook website, a few weeks ago, I opened a Facebook page for my business. Facebook limits business pages to only likes and comments and it does not have the capabilities of a regular personal site.
    When I opened the page, it felt odd to ask personal Facebook contacts to “like” my business with the intention of getting more business. In actuality this would not include my client base or potential clients as I chose to have a private profile.

    This is where I discovered how unimportant Facebook is to my business and marketing plan because I prefer to keep my information private.

    In this manner, I fail to see the importance of my personal Facebook site in relation to increasing my business. (By all means, we can each buy ad space that will pop up while logged in to Facebook, but that’s different).

    I feel strongly about setting a boundary between professional and personal relationships on internet sites.
    Facebook doesn’t let you do this easily.
    For example, I felt shy posting my daughter’s prom pictures knowing potential clients (strangers) might someday have access to these. On the flip side of this, when I posted dialogue regarding our anti-legislative interior design efforts on “Facebook,” it felt awkward that my retired eighty-year old uncle from Missouri would have to possibly see these details of Illinois State’s legislative information that has nothing to do with his life.

    I understand that businesses have tried to exploit the exponential popularity of Facebook to market goods and services.
    However, Facebook wasn’t set up for a professional atmosphere.
    Because once a Facebook account is opened to the public setting, (and if contacts don’t have private accounts) anyone can see pictures of my niece’s newborn son and the posts my son makes about how much he likes Mountain Dew Soda.

    These types of personal posts have no impact on how I run my business or of value in attracting new clients.

    So in turn, I’m using LinkedIn as an alternative.

    Hoping this information is of value to you if you are deciding on which internet sites will work for your business and the value of third party blogging from your internet site to Facebook.
    Elizabeth Bennett, Interior Designer and Admin Manager for several websites

  6. Garth       Reply

    Very interesting topic. You’ve addressed my concerns exactly.

  7. Tyson F. Gautreaux       Reply

    I simply want to mention I am all new to blogging and absolutely loved you’re web blog. Very likely I’m want to bookmark your site . You surely come with wonderful articles and reviews. Thanks for sharing your blog site.

  8. Miss IBC international 2013       Reply

    THE Beauty CONTEST of the YEAR.

  9. online marketing phoenix       Reply

    Wanted to drop a comment and let you know your Feed is not working today. I tried adding it to my Yahoo reader account and got nothing.

  10. internet marketing company oakland ca       Reply

    Wow! This blog is cool. How can I make it look this good ?

  11. Lizzie Coneys       Reply

    Hello! I simply wish to give an enormous thumbs up for the good information you might have right here on this post. I will be coming again to your blog for more soon.

  12. reviews of phen375       Reply

    It really is perfect time to make several plans for the future and it’s time to be happy. I’ve read this post and if I could I desire to recommend you few useful points or advice. Possibly you’ll be able to publish next articles referring to this post. I want to read much more things about it!

  13. agen ibcbet       Reply

    A fascinating debate around casino and betting agencies is worth my comment. I think that you ought to publish more on this subject, it may not be a taboo subject but usually people do not discuss these topics.Casino internet betting it certainly is the most respected and safe means to place your bets at the moment. The signup bonuses and promotions are often an captivating option for online poker. People will likely never obtain all these choices in any physical casino.

  14. iphone repair dublin ca       Reply

    Have you considered including several social bookmarking links to these blogs. At the very least for youtube.

  15. chair mats       Reply

    Hello, I just hopped over to your web page through StumbleUpon. Not somthing I might typically read, but I appreciated your views none the less. Thanks for creating some thing well worth browsing.

  16. secure file server       Reply

    I was basically wanting to know if you ever considered changing the layout of your web site? Its well written; I really like what youve got to state. But maybe you can add a little more in the way of content so people might connect to it better. Youve got a great deal of wording for only having one or two images. Maybe you could space it out better?

  17. go here       Reply

    When are you going to post again? You really inform a lot of people!

  18. success       Reply

    Just discovered this blog through Yahoo, what a pleasant shock!

  19. click       Reply

    The structure for the web site is a tad off in Epiphany. Even So I like your weblog. I might have to install a normal web browser just to enjoy it.

  20. storage facilities       Reply

    Amazing article, thank you, I will subscribe to you RSS later!

  21. Stanley Thoms       Reply

    Remarkable! Its truly amazing paragraph, I have got much clear idea concerning from this post.

  22. your chair mat       Reply

    Please email me with a few hints & tips on how you made this website look this cool , I would be appreciative!

  23. chairmat       Reply

    I love your wp format, where did you get a hold of it?

  24. Celena Fearing       Reply

    100% all natural solution for you to thyrois issues & being pregnant difficulties. If you are concerned with your unborn child’s wellness this is the remedy in your case

  25. kick boxing       Reply

    Hey there! This post couldn’t be written any better! Reading through this post reminds me of my good old room mate! He always kept chatting about this. I will forward this article to him. Pretty sure he will have a good read. Many thanks for sharing!

  26. click for chair mat       Reply

    This really solved my problem, thank you!

  27. rent chairmat       Reply

    Do youve got a spam issue on this internet site; I also am a blogger, and I was questioning your scenario; weve created some great strategies and were searching to swap solutions with other people, be certain to blast me an e-mail if serious.

  28. your chairmats       Reply

    I enjoy your wp layout, where did you get a hold of it?

  29. stimulate hair follicles       Reply

    Prevent Dry Hair Now Using This Type Of Amazing Hair Essential Oil

  30. Filip       Reply


Pin It on Pinterest